admin
Eviction cases can be complex, costly, and emotionally charged. One of the most frequently asked questions in such disputes is: who pays legal fees for eviction? Whether you’re a landlord seeking to remove a tenant or a tenant defending against eviction, understanding how legal costs are allocated is crucial.
Legal fees in eviction proceedings can include court filing fees, attorney fees, service fees, and associated court costs. Who ends up paying these fees depends on several factors, including the lease agreement, state laws, and the outcome of the case.
Landlords Usually Pay Upfront Costs
Since landlords are the ones initiating most eviction proceedings, they are responsible for paying the initial legal fees. This includes filing fees with the court, hiring an attorney (if they choose to), and paying for the service of eviction notices.
The upfront costs can vary significantly depending on the location, complexity of the case, and whether the eviction is contested. In uncontested evictions, the total costs may be modest. However, if the tenant contests the eviction or files counterclaims, the legal costs can quickly escalate.
Despite paying upfront, many landlords hope to recover these costs through court orders or terms specified in the lease.
Can Landlords Recover Legal Fees?
In many cases, landlords can recover legal fees if the lease includes a clause allowing it. These clauses often state that the losing party in a legal dispute must cover the prevailing party’s attorney fees and court costs.
However, whether or not such a clause is enforceable depends on local laws. Some states allow the recovery of attorney fees only if it’s specified in the rental agreement, while others allow courts to award fees at their discretion.
Even if the clause exists, the landlord must win the case for it to be enforceable. If the court rules in favor of the tenant, the landlord cannot recover those fees.
When Tenants Are Ordered to Pay Legal Fees
If a tenant loses the eviction case and the lease includes an attorney fee clause, the court may order the tenant to reimburse the landlord’s legal fees. This can happen in cases involving non-payment of rent, lease violations, or property damage.
In states with fee-shifting statutes, even without a lease clause, tenants may be required to pay the landlord’s legal fees if the landlord wins the case.
However, courts often consider the tenant’s financial circumstances before awarding large legal fees. In some cases, the court may reduce or waive these fees to avoid creating a financial hardship.
What Happens if Tenants Win?
If a tenant successfully defends against an eviction, they may be able to recover their own legal costs—especially if the lease includes a mutual attorney fee clause or if local laws allow it.
Tenants represented by legal aid organizations may not owe attorney fees, but if they hire private counsel and win, they could request that the landlord cover their costs.
The Role of the Lease Agreement
Ultimately, the lease agreement plays a major role in determining who pays legal fees. Both landlords and tenants should read and understand this section before signing. A well-drafted lease can clarify fee responsibilities and help avoid disputes later.
Final Thoughts
Legal fees in eviction cases are not automatically assigned to one party. While landlords typically pay upfront, tenants can be held responsible if the court sides with the landlord and the lease allows fee recovery. Likewise, tenants may recover costs if they win the case. Knowing your rights, reviewing your lease, and understanding local laws can make a significant difference in how much you end up paying in an eviction dispute.
